My friend had a rather nasty encounter last night. He’s a JC student. Apparently he and his friends were at City Hall MRT station last night after a concert. His friend took out some chocolate to eat in the MRT station which of course is not allowed. She was warned once by the MRT official. They persisted awhile later and the station master came down and informed them that they would have to be fined (I think the fine is supposed to be $500). Now this is all well and good because yes, they did break the law, knowingly, even after having been warned the first time. So I have no quibble with that.
But…my friend followed the two girls up to the control station. As the station master was speaking to the girls, my friend happened to notice a man coming through the gantries with a half-filled (I’m an optimist) cup of iced coffee in his hand, sipping from it through a straw. My friend told the station master to look at the man, expecting him to apprehend or at least warn the man as well, but the station master got very snippy with him, demanding to know if he was “challenging” him, telling them they were only students and should have “basic courtesy”, didn’t warn the other man at all, and threatened to call the police on them. You can read the account below.
I’m pissed off because it sounds like the station master is some frustrated employee with a power trip, and while he had a legitimate reason to apprehend the two girls for eating chocolate in the MRT station I certainly don’t see any reason for him being so aggressive and repeatedly demanding, “Are you challenging me?” when my friend also repeatedly said he was not, and even apologized. I don’t see any reason for him to stop two girls eating chocolate and holding them up for so long but when another man, drinking, was pointed out to him, he chose to do nothing about it.
M says:
i want to rant about last night
last night choir had to perform for ajc choir thing
as guest choir
so we ended around 9
then we went to city hall mrt in one group
and one of the girls was hungry so she took out chocolate to eat
the station people say cannot eat
so she kept
we went in
and she took out to eat anyway
and continued eating
which is wrong
so another girl ask for some chocolate too
so the station master came down and ask the 2 girls to go up
say he need to fine them
so i went up after some time to see
he says he has to uphold policy
account to his boss that hes doing his job
say he caught everything with his 153 cctvs
then i was looking another group of people walking thru the gantry
one guy had this huge cup of ice coffee
like half full
straw in his mouth
obviously drinking
so i tell the station master
“look over there”
he refuses to look and stares at me
i say “look over there that guy is drinking”
“why dont you warn him”
he looks
then he looks at me and says
“ARE YOU CHALLENGING ME?”
and he repeated the question like a dozen times
i say no
i just ask why u pick this girl out but u don’t do anything to that guy over there
then he say something like
i mean
he just totally ignored my question
then he said if he fine that guy he will fine her too
then he ask again are you challenging me
i say no
then he ask again
and again
i say no
again
and again
then he say i can easily call the police
then he ask are you challenging me
i say no
i didnt want to get that girl into more trouble so i apologize
then he says to me
said to all of us actually but particularly to me
“you are JUST STUDENTS”
“you are ONLY STUDENTS”
“basic courtesy you should know”
he said that like dunno how many umpteen times
then he says to everyone and stares at me
im not trying to create trouble for all of you
to me “ok sir?”
like some sarcastic manner
then the girl started crying
then he said i actually dont want to fine and yada yada
so in the end never fine
and whatever
but i’m disgusted
i’m a consumer of their services
i should be treated like one
but im viewed as “only a student”
if other people werent involved i wouldve asked him to go ahead and call the police
-jadeite- says:
well if they had called the police you probably would have had to pay the fine
M says:
no
he has no right to fine
because
i made sure
he saw someone else drinking
but he didnt fine that person
additionally
-jadeite- says:
being a devil’s advocate here: on one hand it is not about “look, that man is doing it too,” but your friend having done something that is expressly forbidden and already having been warned
M says:
he constantly stated “you are only students”
this shows bias
so why
but he still has no right to fine because he is selectively apply this supposed law
and his 153 cctvs must have caught that guy drinking too
so these rules apply to us just because we are students?
someone else who doesnt come in in uniform can eat and drink?
and adult can walk in eating and drinking?
i need to know my consumer rights
i do have the right to question why only a selected group of people should have to abide to the law
and why he blatantly didnt take the effort to “uphold his policies” on others
he says he needs to be accountable to his boss that hes doing his job
but he clearly isnt
-jadeite- says:
well you do have to understand on a moral point of view…if you are caught for stealing you can’t plead for mercy just because other people steal, too, so why aren’t you catching them?
but you’re right, the onus is on him to extend the same manner of jurisdiction on others
M says:
proof of that is he knowingly allowed others to enter
i wasnt the one who broke the law
but yet he singled me out
as “you are just a student”
-jadeite- says:
but your friend also has to accept that she shldn’t have eaten the chocolate
haih that part is disgusting
did you get his name?
M says:
no
but he is station master of city hall
very big sized guy
hard to miss
but i still dont think he has the right to fine the girl when he didnt fine, or even bother to warn someone else
my point is that he was aware of it right at that moment
and he was able to act on it
but he didn’t
not to mention he threatened me with the police
and accused me of challenging him
my friend was shocked
she was crying
ironic thing is the trains had the advertisement
courtesy starts with a smile
or some nonsense like that
i really wonder what he wouldve said to the police
like im reporting a case of two girls eating chocolate
and a guy who is being rude to me
how is he being rude?
uh, well
he didnt use vulgarities
he apologized to me
and uh
-_-